By Alice Park
The uproar in the medical community was immediate. In a reversal of standard practice that bewildered physicians and patients around the nation, an independent government panel this week abandoned its long-standing recommendation that healthy women over age 40 get a breast-cancer screen once every year or two years. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force began advising women instead to delay regular screening until age 50, and even then, to get tested only every other year.
The American Cancer Society promptly declared it would not modify its guidelines that healthy women over 40 get yearly mammograms. Secretary of Health and Human Services Kathleen Sebelius stated that the government's "policies remain unchanged." And most physicians say they will continue to recommend annual mammograms for women over 40. Meanwhile, thousands of women across the country have been left confused and anxious.
Members of the government panel expected a backlash, but the magnitude of the public response was a revelation. "It's surprising to me not only the amount of reaction but the emotionality and the degree to which this has caused upset," says Dr. Diana Petitti, vice chair of the task force.
The 16-member panel found that yearly mammograms unquestionably reduced the risk of dying from breast cancer 15% in women under 50. But when weighed against the risks of screening — false positives, additional biopsies and patient anxiety — the relative benefit was too small to recommend screening in younger women. That conclusion has incensed some oncologists. "They are saying that we should take mammography away from women in their 40s because ... these factors outweigh the value of lives saved," says Dr. David Dershaw at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center.
Given the backdrop of health care reform and insurers' preoccupation with cost containment, the major concern is that women under 50 may now stand to lose insurance coverage for mammography — a preventive test that Medicare is mandated to pay for. But Sebelius rejected the notion. The task force does not "set federal policy, and they don't determine what services are covered by the Federal Government," she said. On the part of the task force, Petitti says the cost of mammography was never mentioned in the panel's discussions.
Still, if confused and frustrated women begin opting out of screening altogether, changing guidelines could erode progress that has been made in reducing breast-cancer deaths. Says Dr. George Sledge, president-elect of the American Society of Clinical Oncologists: "If the end result of all of this were to diminish the number of women having mammograms, then that would be a tragedy."
source: Time.com
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(2302)
-
▼
November
(324)
- Adam Lambert Going in New Direction After Controve...
- 'True Blood' Finds Sam's Brother, Looking for Mom
- 'The Hobbit' Filming Pushed Back Until Mid 2010, C...
- Jude Law and Sienna Miller Keep Adding Fuel to Rec...
- Tiger Woods withdraws from tournament, not talking
- Fashion show of Miss World 2009 competitors
- Poland's top designer Michal Starost women's fashi...
- Lopburi's ‘monkey buffet’
- Our collection of wild custom cars
- Toilet tour of India
- Shanghai dining trends that deserve to die
- Want to Boost Your Memory? Try Sleeping on It
- The Mammogram Melee: How Much Screening Is Best?
- King Bhumibol, who will be turning 82 on December 5
- Pictures of Alexandra Burke's 'Broken Heels' Music...
- Grant Bowler Cast on 'True Blood' Season 3
- Tobey Maguire Wants to Evolve Peter Parker in 'Spi...
- Derek Jeter Builds Colossal Mansion to Share With ...
- the 2010 winner alongside the outgoing 2009 Miss D...
- NFL football game in San Diego, California Novembe...
- 64 Santa Clauses from toy store march on a Tokyo s...
- The Miss International Beauty Pageant 2009
- NCAA college football game in Los Angeles.
- A Monkey drinks Cola
- Sophia Bush Tells All About Beauty and Fashion Choice
- BATON ROUGE, LA - NOVEMBER 28
- 20 new gadgets for holiday shopping
- Golfer Tiger Woods Injured in Crash
- Black Friday Sales Were Encouraging, Retailers Say
- Official Tracklisting for Lil Wayne's 'Rebirth'
- 'Ugly Betty' 4.08 Preview: Shakira Guest Starring
- Jeremy Renner May Be Hawkeye, Not Captain America
- More Details Exposed in Tiger Woods' Alleged Affai...
- Cartoons of the Week, November 28, 2009 - December...
- NBA basketball game in Indianapolis, Friday, Nov. ...
- Japan launched its fifth spy satellite
- Top 10 Urban Biking Trips
- Top 10: Female Sex Fantasies
- Doc Love: Dating Other People
- Video: Katharine McPhee Performs at 2009 Macy's Th...
- Holiday Movie Guide: The December Movies to Check ...
- Holiday Movie Guide: The December Movies to Check ...
- the 83rd annual Macy's Thanksgiving Day parade on ...
- Thanksgiving meals for homeless people
- Thanksgiving -- the Unique American Feast Day
- Macy's parade balloon preparation now a tradition,...
- Video: Adam Lambert Performs on CBS' 'The Early Show'
- Preview of 'Glee' 1.12: Mattress
- 'Toy Story 3' Unleashes International Trailer
- Joanna Krupa's Nude PETA Pic Unleashed
- Are Vampires Real? The Science Behind the Myth
- the Italian TV show 'Chiambretti Night'
- Top 10: Things To Bring On Thanksgiving
- News Today, November 25, 2009
- Video: Rihanna Performs on 'Good Morning America'
- Official Tracklisting for Alicia Keys' 'The Elemen...
- 'Glee' Bumped Until April, Paired With 'American I...
- Angelina Jolie and Johnny Depp's Possible Sex Scen...
- Miley Cyrus Says 'New Moon' Is Cult, Johnny Depp H...
- NBA basketball game in Los Angeles, Tuesday, Nov. ...
- Recipes for Health, Pear and Apple Soufflé
- Sounds During Sleep Aid Memory, Study Finds
- In Holiday Season Adjusted for Recession, Chicago ...
- Holiday Gift Guide 2009
- Save Money While Traveling
- Top 10: Reasons Sex Makes Men Healthier
- Christmas market in front of the Charlottenburg ca...
- Christmas illuminations at the Champs Elysees aven...
- NCAA college basketball game Monday, Nov. 23, 2009...
- Kelis' New Song 'Acapella' Arrives
- 'Dancing with the Stars' Finale Recap: Mya on the ...
- First 'Hobbit' Film Gets Complete Script
- Inside Miley Cyrus' Surprise 17th Birthday Party
- Djokovic Serbs up a treat
- ATP World Tour Finals Title in London
- Miss International Beauty Pageant 2009
- World's Tallest Model Graces Magazine Cover
- Eva Mendes Interview
- Home Gym Equipment: Guy Gear
- the Miss Earth 2009 beauty pageant, Larissa Ramos ...
- Christmas at a mall in Beijing, China
- 2009 AMAs: Full Winners List, Taylor Swift Takes T...
- Brian and Ericka Spared 'Amazing Race' Elimination
- Shooting of Tom Cruise's 'Knight and Day' Suspende...
- Video: Jennifer Lopez Takes a Tumble During AMAs P...
- the 2009 American Music Awards
- Job fair for sales students
- Twilight Sequel New Moon Sets Records at the Box O...
- the Miss International Beauty Pageant 2009
- US healthcare bill passes first Senate hurdle in vote
- Is It Time For Sex Therapy?
- Megan Fox to Get 'Great Part' in 'Transformers 3'
- Alexa Vega Engaged to Boyfriend Sean Covel
- ''Marie Lifestyle'' accessories and home decor col...
- Sand sculpture on Boracay island in Malay
- WBC World Champion title fight in Kiel, northern G...
- Meeting with Pope Benedict XVI at the Vatican, Sat...
- Spanish La Liga soccer match at the Santiago Berna...
- The funeral of late French actor Jocelyn Quivrin
- The exhibition of a creche crafting club in Vienna
-
▼
November
(324)