A Noble Lecture
Posted by Joe Klein
Oslo
How does a rookie President, having been granted the Nobel Peace Prize, go about earning it? Well, he can start by giving the sort of Nobel lecture that Barack Obama just did, an intellectually rigorous and morally lucid speech that balanced the rationale for going to war against the need to build a more peaceful and equitable world. The first half of the speech, in which the President made the case for Just Wars, will be the part that makes news. It was especially notable because it was delivered to an elite European audience, denizens of a continent where the most vicious warfare conducted in the history of humankind has been replaced by a facile moral superiority (made possible by the U.S. force of arms during the Cold War). But Obama's clarity would also have been useful last week when he gave a more grudging, less straightforward, speech at West Point, announcing his decision to send more troops to Afghanistan.
Here are the crucial paragraphs, which bear close reading:
We must begin by acknowledging the hard truth: We will not eradicate violent conflict in our lifetimes. There will be times when nations -- acting individually or in concert -- will find the use of force not only necessary but morally justified.
I make this statement mindful of what Martin Luther King Jr. said in this same ceremony years ago: "Violence never brings permanent peace. It solves no social problem: it merely creates new and more complicated ones." As someone who stands here as a direct consequence of Dr. King's life work, I am living testimony to the moral force of non-violence. I know there's nothing weak -- nothing passive -- nothing naïve -- in the creed and lives of Gandhi and King.
But as a head of state sworn to protect and defend my nation, I cannot be guided by their examples alone. I face the world as it is, and cannot stand idle in the face of threats to the American people. For make no mistake: Evil does exist in the world. A non-violent movement could not have halted Hitler's armies. Negotiations cannot convince al Qaeda's leaders to lay down their arms. To say that force may sometimes be necessary is not a call to cynicism -- it is a recognition of history; the imperfections of man and the limits of reason.
I raise this point, I begin with this point because in many countries there is a deep ambivalence about military action today, no matter what the cause. And at times, this is joined by a reflexive suspicion of America, the world's sole military superpower.
There is something remarkably gutsy about using Martin Luther King Jr. as a foil before the Nobel Committee, which elevated King, and his movement, into an international moral crusade. But Obama brought it off. The audience didn't applaud until the end, when it exploded; it was one of those audiences that was concentrating too hard on the words to interrupt the speaker.
The second half of the speech, about peace-making, was well-written and delivered, but it was more the sort of thing a Nobel audience is used to hearing: a call for stronger international institutions, a defense of basic human rights and greater economic equity.
Obama closed with an assault on the religious fanatics responsible for much of the bloodshed in the world and offered an aphorism that will undoubtedly make its way into compilations of deathless quotations: "No holy war can ever be a just war."
(Read more...)
source: swampland.blogs.time.com
Blog Archive
-
▼
2009
(2302)
-
▼
December
(255)
- Fireworks light up the London skyline and Big Ben ...
- New Year's Eve celebrations in New York's Times Sq...
- Celebrate the New Year January 1, 2010., Sydney
- Happy 2010! Sydney kicks off the New Year as celeb...
- As six die in snow, is this family the daftest in ...
- It's back home to Mother: Year of recession forces...
- An injection of gas could help you lose weight
- Brrrangelina: Jolie and Pitt wrap up their kids in...
- Father shoots dead daughter, 4, maims ex-lover the...
- Is Tiger Woods still playing around with Rachel Uc...
- New 'Daybreakers' Clip: Vampire Attack
- Wolves 0 Manchester City 3: Roberto Mancini works ...
- Would YOU be happy to take the 'naked' body scan?
- Jennifer Lopez puts on stunning show as a denim diva
- Home Office uses new advertisements to warn Brits ...
- British skier missing in the Alps found dead: Man ...
- Pomegranate lotion offers new hope in war on super...
- The only thing stopping you from getting what you ...
- Wayne Rooney fired up by fear of Fergie as he help...
- Just like old times: Jude Law and Sienna Miller so...
- The wider view: A miniature homage to the palace o...
- Dog charity refuses to rehouse animals over the fe...
- The couple who wash the dishes together will stay ...
- Is that the Queen in Tesco? (... and on the Number...
- Syringe bomber of Flight 253 detonates explosives ...
- Unveiled: China's 245mph train service is the worl...
- Video Premiere: Gucci Mane's 'Bingo' Feat. Soulja Boy
- 'Castle' Preview: Alyssa Milano Guest Stars
- Pics of Corbin Bleu, Bonnie Hunt and More Serving ...
- Lovebirds Ali Bastian and Brian Fortuna triumph in...
- Top adventure breaks to make the most of a winter ...
- By Arthur Martin, Tom Kelly and Scott Warren Teres...
- Jet Li's 'The Warlords' Drops New Trailer
- Mary J. Blige Punching Her Husband at New Album Re...
- Vatican drama: Pope attacked at Midnight Mass by S...
- Santa Claus
- Mary J. Blige Desires Anita Baker for Jazz Album
- 'Lost' Death: It's Either Sayid or Jack
- Bruce Willis Tickling in New Trailer for 'Cop Out'
- Taylor Swift Hopes to Get Soft Furnishings This Ch...
- Big freeze threat to family Christmas: As death to...
- Insane Amounts of Christmas Lights!
- Top 10: Scary Girlfriend Behaviors
- Lady GaGa Spotted With Alleged New Boyfriend
- Sex by 16 'can harm academic prospects' because te...
- Prince William sleeps rough in freezing back alley...
- Brittany Murphy's husband to be quizzed over her d...
- 'Suvivor: Samoa' Winner and Runner Up Talk Surpris...
- Tom Cruise's 'Knight and Day' Gets First Trailer
- Nicole Scherzinger and Lewis Hamilton on the Verge...
- British soldier serving in Afghanistan for Christm...
- The Beckhams enjoy a rare family day out as they h...
- Homes in suburban Sydney are decorated with Christ...
- Promotional Ads for Eminem's 'Relapse: Refill'
- 'Avatar' Tops Weekend Box Office Chart
- Father Remembers Recently-Passed Brittany Murphy
- 10 ways to avoid mother-in-law meltdown this Chris...
- Brittany Murphy dies 'from a heart attack' aged 32
- Christmas getaway chaos as heavy snow closes roads...
- Cartoons of the Week, December 19-25, 2009
- 'White Collar' Officially Gets Season 2
- Trailer for Jennifer Lopez's 'The Back-Up Plan' Ar...
- Kanye West to Marry Amber Rose Next Year
- It's panic Saturday: High Street giants slash pric...
- A Bachelor's Guide to Holiday Cooking
- Going To A Potluck? Impress Everyone
- John Frusciante Quits Red Hot Chili Peppers, Again
- Idina Menzel's Role on 'Glee' Not Yet Confirmed
- 'Spider-Man 4' Production Not Halted, Sony Says
- Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart Enjoy Private...
- 'I'm 47, how am I supposed to look,' says Demi Moo...
- Tiger Woods's mistress Theresa Rogers 'demands £2m...
- Giant Christmas tree at Paris and Others
- Christmas Tree party at Monaco Palace
- Director's Cut of Britney Spears' '3' Music
- You could be lining children up for life of addict...
- Two boys, aged 10, charged with raping eight-year-...
- Was pop singer Jessica Simpson another of Tiger Wo...
- Final 'Lost' Art Project Unveiled
- More Details Uncovered on Reese Witherspoon and Ja...
- Fears of travel chaos as weathermen warn south of ...
- The bespoke cancer 'cure': Patients could get spec...
- Sarah Jessica Parker proudly shows off photo of he...
- Study: Airport Noise Increases Risk of Strokes
- How To: Be The Cool Uncle (At Christmas)
- Drinking three cups of tea or coffee a day cuts ri...
- Sneak Peek to Justin Bieber Singing on 'Christmas ...
- Jack Black Coming to 'Community'
- A Look at 'Scott Pilgrim vs. the World' Characters...
- Sacha Baron Cohen and Isla Fisher Have Set Wedding...
- Top 10 Toy Crazes
- Rated X: Rihanna's naughty makeover continues with...
- Army widow joins Calendar Girls-style effort to ra...
- Gorgeous in garters Gossip Girl Taylor Momsen keep...
- Wallmart Denies Boycotting Chris Brown's 'Graffiti'
- First Look at 'How I Met Your Mother' Musical Episode
- Tobey Maguire NOT In Talks to Play Bilbo Baggins
- Kate Hudson and Alex Rodriguez Break Up
- Brother and sister barred from school's Christmas ...
- Sherlock Holmes: Leading ladies Rachel McAdams and...
-
▼
December
(255)